Cartel Empire is a great example of how PBBGs can look when the right attention is given to the right things.
It's very well polished, from UX to the game mechanics to the community features and more. The developer is also active and friendly, which is always nice to see.
I'm not normally that interested in crime-based games, but I've stuck with this one so far due to the overall high quality experience. The early game and tutorial were fun, and there is a variety of options for how long different activities take, which allows me to vary my activity level depending on the day while still feeling like I'm making progress.
The only reason I'm not giving it 5 stars is because there are slight UX improvements to be made, but nothing that is too disruptive. Still though, it's a very strong 4 and will definitely be an example I refer to when talking about PBBGs done well.
I look forward to seeing how it evolves. :)
I enjoy the general presentation. It's got some character for sure, although it doesn't offer anything obviously unique.
I have mixed feelings on the p2w aspect. My biggest beef is that it isn't super obvious up front that there is any payment aspect. I had to dig around the wiki to find the info about Dragon Tokens which was a bit off putting. p2w itself isn't always a problem, but it's hard not to make assumptions when information is so tucked away.
That may be a general problem with the game itself; its documentation. There is a wiki that has a decent amount of information but there isn't a general high level explanation of what's going on in terms of story or larger setting. For example, registering requires you to "pick a side" but it isn't clear what difference it makes aside from character class options. Why should I care what side I choose? I want to know more than just a generic light vs dark battle.
The other big thing that bugged me was the level requirement to post in the forums. That seems unfriendly to new players and unnecessarily exclusive. The admin feels hard to get ahold of.
All that said, I do see potential. The quest option doesn't currently work but when it did, there seemed to be a spark of depth. The UI/UX feels nice if just a bit tedious at times. The in-game chat/events works well. The number of things to do and places to go feels large enough to sustain engagement and curiousity.
I rate it a 3/5. If the game setting/lore and communication issues are fixed up I can see it being a solid 4, but for now it just barely misses the mark.