pbbg.com
pbbg.com

Reviewer

Strom
2 public reviews.

Jul 16, 2019

Marosia is a game currently in development with a lot of potential, and a really engaged, loyal playerbase that really bring it to life. However, in my own personal opinion, the game falls short due to heartfelt but mis-managed development and a slightly stifled community - I don't think this ruins the game entirely, I just think as of writing this review it has a long way to go - which I believe is acknowledged in the fact it is in open beta. Something to take into consideration. Gameplay - 3/5 This should be 4/5, but I'll explain why. As far as how the game works, how it players and the direction it is going in, Marosia is actually a really fun and engaging game with a lot of mechanics that are open-ended, which is great. The developer has an excellent base from which the game is being built up from, and it shows. Since playing the game, I've had a lot of fun stories and roleplay develop, and the game itself is very enjoyable the play. The only reason it doesn't get the four is because firstly, it has a long way to go before it meets it's own goals, and secondly there are a few decisions made regarding mechanics that are often met with some backlash or imbalance the game, but are implemented anyway. Community - 2/5 Again, the community score should be higher and I'll explain why. Firstly, as a good point, the Marosia community is in general both welcoming and friendly to any newcomers, and always happy to help in anyway they can. In the wider scheme of things, they are also excellent players in general, and high quality RPers. It however loses some points in my opinion for a variety of reasons. Firstly, there are some incredibly stifling and strict set of OOC rules that otherwise prevent any real discussions going on about the game outside of it. Whilst it has been explained WHY these rules have been placed and enforced, and I as a player can understand some of them, quite often they are arbitrarily and often harshly/aggressively enforced to the point of suffocation. Your character is dead? Can't talk about them. Event is still technically "open" and hasn't concluded? Can't talk about it. Want to post about something in game? Is it a spoiler? Has it ever been mentioned? Is it something ongoing? And so on, and so on. In my own opinion this can seem incredibly paranoid and condescending in regards to more experienced roleplayers/players like myself who are capable of separation and just want to chat, however I do accept the vision for the game is to remain entirely and overwhelmingly IC. My only MAJOR gripe is that there does seem to be a player presence who abuse the "no OOC" rule and seem to be trying to make the game as difficult as possible for other people with rather disturbing RP (which is deemed okay), and yet despite everything haven't yet been removed. However, whether this is down to lack of concrete evidence or a lack of interest in enforcing is unclear to me. Development - 1/5 I want to make it clear that the developer is clearly very active, very motivated and very involved in the development of Marosia, and these are all good things to have in a lead developer. They have also built a solid system, are ROUTINELY active in troubleshooting and issue resolving, and have been the sole creator of a very interesting lore base from which the players generally have had fun developing from. However, as the sole developer the game is severely hampered by some odd mechanical choices that make little to no sense regarding the world (child characters from the age of 6 inheriting skills rather than stats, which ends up with six year olds being master smiths where thirty year olds barely make apprentice) which can often be frustrating for immersion, and any criticism is often received indifferently at best, and badly at worst. What's more, there are more than enough examples of clear favouritism (whether this is because of patron status, personal friendships with the developer or simply a player being more active in general I do not know) that significantly unbalance the game - this can include entire families possessing significant boosts to skills, gods favouring individual characters (and indeed players), and characters receiving items or boosts. Conclusion - 2/5 All in all, Marosia is an alright game built on solid foundations that could develop into a much more immersive, fun experience depending on where it goes, but is let down by current development. I fully intend to keep playing and supporting the game (even financially), as I feel it has a lot of potential to become more, and my review should be taken wtih a pinch of salt given that it is, by its own admission, still a beta. EDIT: As of January 2020, the above review is no longer valid, but I am leaving it as a point of transparency. The below review is my most current, and as a disclaimer I will say that in the spirit of honesty, I am a Founder, so there is an element of bias. However, my reviews always strive to be honest. Marosia is a game currently in development with a lot of potential, and a really engaged, loyal playerbase that really bring it to life. However, in my own personal opinion, the game falls short due to heartfelt but mis-managed development and a slightly stifled community - I don't think this ruins the game entirely, I just think as of writing this review it has a long way to go - which I believe is acknowledged in the fact it is in open beta. Something to take into consideration. Gameplay - 4/5 Gameplay remains mostly unchanged, but what bumps up the score this time around is a deluge of newly implemented features that improve the game in a big way - increased experience-gain difficult, windows to buildings, a reset to the world complete with new and exciting lore, a team of Gods that work to facilitate RP without driving it too heavily instead of players, new resources (with changes to old resources) - it only gets four because it's not quite a finished polished game, but may bump to five in the future if half of the stuff being promised actually ends up in the game. Community - 5/5 I really can't fault the community. I hate to say it, but the old community's bad apples seem to have worked their way out in the process of the game going down and coming back again - and whilst there is always going to be bad apples (and it's subjective anyway), the current community love the game and other players so much that they kept a discord community going even after the game went down, and both the developers and the players have poured so much effort into "New Marosia". The Founders are active and driven, the player base is welcoming and friendly (still are) and everyone seems to be pouring a lot of love into the project. Development - 4/5 The new development team is a small group of dedicated developers, and who work together really well to provide as fair as possible "service" to the playerbase. There is a wealth of experience and ability between the team, and whilst there have been a few hiccups, they are open to suggestion, easy to approach, and are extremely dedicated to their responsibilities as the DM's of the game world. There are no special privileges, and whilst there are "special characters", they don't have any more power than any other character in the game. Conclusion - 4/5 Marosia is still in a "beta" of sorts (in fact its further back in the process), and thus is far from finished and far from perfect, however the new direction, management and constant changes seem to be going in the right direction for a much higher score in the future.

Jul 16, 2019

Definitely one of my more favourite browser games available, but just short of perfect. Gameplay - 4/5 As far as gameplay goes, this game is nothing spectacular. However, I don't think that works to it's detriment, given that it's a text based roleplaying/battle browser game. Despite being extremely rudimentary (and perhaps a little bit ugly), the fact it is such an old game doesn't quite do it's justice with how much stuff is available to do. I don't quite give it five stars, because some of the mechanics at play make no sense or are not enjoyable, but I don't mark it lower because those choices are clearly done to better balance the game, which I think is admirable. Community - 4/5 The community behind Battlemaster is in general really good - there is a really great community spirit of 'fair play' and allowing everyone a chance to shine. Most if not all of the players are friendly, helpful, and more than willing to contribute to enjoyment within the game. The only reason it doesn't get full marks is because there is a small presence of 'old guard' who seem unwilling to share the sandpit or take the game far too seriously (in direct conflict with the community spirit), and that none of the development team want to actually tackle, though admittedly at the time of writing this the vast majority of them have been removed or left. Other than this, I don't think I've come across a more welcoming and open community, falling just short of the full five stars for the player base. Development - 3/5 Although the development team side of the game only gets 3 stars imo, but I cannot stress this isn't because they are bad at what they do. Battlemaster has a very dedicated and very hard working group of volunteer developers who, although slow, operate as professionally and as conscientiously as they can when it comes to mechanical choices, further development and even dishing out punishments on players. The only reason I personally give them 3/5 is because there seems to be a small obsession with removing agency from players and roleplayers, and almost railroading them into certain decisions they feel is best. For example, quite often small realms are "guilt tripped" into considering merging with other, larger realms (using the excuse of 'think of the new players', which IS valid) but often comes at the expense of dismissing the roleplay and culture of certain roleplay circles. There also seems to be a worrying habit of the dev team supporting the destruction of smaller realms by bigger realms, though they only ever seem to get involved in a superficial manner rather than directly, which is good. Conclusion - 4/5 All in all, Battlemaster is a really fun game for those that don't mind an ancient looking UI in exchange for quite engaging gameplay features, and as a roleplayer I genuinely have enjoyed what the platforms offers. It falls short of full marks due to my own biases as to the age of the game, but I have genuinely enjoyed my interactions with the community and the dev team, and made some excellent friends along the way.