Mar 20, 2023
I'd played Maro for a few years now- I was there for the end of the second owner's era, into the new owner and their withdrawal and handover of control to the current head admin. The game and community have always had their flaws, but while a few of the positive reviews claim that the negative ones are more reviews of the community than the game, I feel the overlap is integral- you cannot review the game itself without reviewing the community. In fact, one of the things Marosia advertises itself on is the lack of NPCs and how every character is played by a real player, Unless you make every single one of your characters a hermit you will be impacted by the community. And this is a problem. The only way to know who plays a character is to be part of the greater community, namely the discord as the forums are effectively dead. There is no other way to communicate with a player out of character. The possibility of anonymity would be nice, but the staff and certain community members have been pushing for "spicier" plots, by which they mean such things as kidnapping and torture. Unless you know the other players involved, there is no way to negotiate what you're comfortable playing out. (And staff have repeatedly spoken against this negotiation, claiming it hurts their immersion, which is naturally more important than player safety.) Fades to black are the only in-game tool available to avoid certain kinds of content. RP posts are supposed to avoid godmodding, but there's nothing mechanically stopping you from, say, being beaten down until you can be dragged, then pulled into a vehicle or building. You can fade to black on the details, but if something happens mechanically, such as an injury or a kidnapping, it can't be ignored. "But Twice!" The staff have said, "It's fine because you have options! You can leave! You can go in a locked room before you're beaten to immobility or injury! You can completely ignore whatever's going on if it's too spicy for you!" The first options are purely mechanical and ignore in-character pressures: if it would undermine the fundamentals of your character to walk away from, say, their family being threatened, staff will blame you for not taking the mechanical way out. If you get caught in a situation you're not comfortable with it will often come down to staying true to your character or to your health. And if the mechanics aren't on your side? If you're locked in a room with someone? Your only options are to fade to black, which won't protect you from getting hit every hour by them, or not post at all and hope they get bored, which also won't protect you from the mechanics of it. The very things staff will suggest if you don't want to be involved are mocked by the head admin openly in community. 'Sighing and closing the window' has reached meme status as a response to in-character drama, despite one of the things players are told to do if they don't want to be part of a scene is to remove themself from it- such as by closing a window. Reports about behavior are often dismissed. For months people around a certain player's characters complained about them, both in reports and in community. Players were told not to shit on a valid playstyle (said 'playstyle' being a transparent power trip, overly aggressive, never letting themself lose or be wrong, and about as fun to be around as a needle in your eye.) We were told to handle the problem in character, which they took advantage of due to the problem I mentioned before of players being caught between being true to their character and wanting to solve the problem: many of the people in the towns they were in were patient, or kind, or too busy trying to do damage control. Both their worst-offending characters were children who had grown up in the towns, and their families were unwilling to take extreme measures. Players put their characters in long hibernation or culled entirely, and when they went to staff for help were blamed for not doing enough on their own. Even after a tirade from the offending player in community about the players who hibernated or refused to engage, it was months before they were banned. Staff's response to bad actors is a joke. One player was banned from the community, but not from the game itself. They continue to publicly push fetish content in the game (not the thing for which they were banned from the discord,) which is openly laughed about by staff in community. Suicide and self-harm are allowed but per the rules have to be kept to private areas and with a chance for witnesses to remove themselves. Graphic self-harm and suicide attempts have happened outside in major towns, with the player facing no apparent consequences. There are rules against rape, but in practice they only cover explicit assault. Attempts to emotionally manipulate characters into either entering or remaining in sexual relationships are apparently fine unless the targeted character openly says no, leaving the player trapped once more between their character's responses and their own safety. Reports are usually replied to, but the response often amounts to "there's no hard evidence of malicious intent so we've elected not to do anything about it." Many players have given up on sending reports entirely, feeling unheard. For months I tried to push many of my friends into reporting rule breaks, hoping that the situation would improve. Their and my own reports were met with lukewarm responses, answer after answer of "well it looks bad but not bad enough," or even "well it looks bad from the outside but we're sure there's nothing REALLY wrong, handle it in-game if it bothers you." The implication seems to be that if you can be subtle enough you can get away with nearly anything and the staff won't lift a finger. Players who flagrantly break the rules are given second chances, then third, then fourth, despite the severity of their offenses. A player might be warned repeatedly, then suspended repeatedly, but bans are rare as owl's teeth. And if you don't respond perfectly to being subject to a rule break- if you participate at all, or fail to participate in the way they expect you to, their dismissal of the problem will include blaming you, or telling you that your response was just as wrong and they're magnanimously refraining from punishing you as well as not punishing the offender. If you want a lawless wild west of a game where you can be exposed to anything whether you want to be or not as long as it's done with a subtle hand, Marosia's the game for you. You'll encounter some excellent players if you're willing to brave the possibility of characters diving headfirst into your pants, watching someone carve words into their body in the town square, risk being pushed into indentured servitude or kidnapped while you're hibernated, the gamble of being born an incest baby to parents who knew better, or being snarked about in the community for not wanting to get involved with the latest drama. Remember! All play styles are valid unless you want any control over the plot lines you get involved with, or if you want to play a low-impact, low-drama character. If you want to curate your experience at all, choose who you interact with and how, or want your reports to have literally any impact, I suggest you avoid it.